Thursday, April 4, 2019

The Shame of Secrecy. The Secrecy of Shame

If your family kept secrets and never talked about hard things, you grow up feeling a lot of shame and loneliness about struggling. 
Healing comes in relationships with people who don't live like there's shame in talking about hard things. 
And don't pretend not to struggle.
~notesfromyourtherapist, Instagram

The first person I called was my mother. And like good mothers throughout history she immediately and completely was in my corner. She expressed empathy, support and a rock-solid faith in me. She didn't vilify my husband but held him accountable. She held me, she listened to me and she was always, always on the other end of that phone when I needed her.
I was lucky.
Others, not so much.
I hear often from you about how abandoned you feel. Your mothers won't talk about it or you're afraid to tell them. Your siblings take sides or cast judgement. Your friends, in the interest of supporting you, insist that the only way to respond is to file for divorce. 
And that's if you tell anyone at all. Far more often, we don't. We hold our secret close. And it poisons us. 
It poisons us because secrets carry shame. Even if we know, in our heads, that we are not the reason he cheated. Even if we understand that people don't cheat because there's something wrong with their spouse, they cheat because there's something wrong with them. Because they're lost or afraid or lonely and they don't know how to feel those feelings and so they avoid and they distract and they lie to themselves and others. 
Their secrets have poisoned them. 
My family kept the secret of my parents' addictions. And because I was young, I learned that I should be ashamed. Why else would I not being able to talk about what was really going on at home. It must be shameful. It must be kept hidden. Nobody had to tell me that, of course. It was understood. And that silence, that secrets poisoned me for a lot of years.
When my mother got sober and began telling her story (she took her 12 steps seriously and wrote letters of apology and shared her story far and wide), I slowly began sharing mine. I was leery. In my twenties, at a time when there wasn't nearly the cultural conversation around addiction that there is now, I knew I was opening myself up to judgement. But what I've learned since is that no-one's judgement was harsher than my own. Nothing anyone ever said to me matched my own feelings of shame, that I still needed to wrestle with.
It has been a similar experience with my husband's infidelity.
I told my mother but very very few others. One of those others cast judgement, which sent me scurrying back into my silence. 
And that's mostly where I stayed. Silent. And filled with shame.
Until I began telling my story here. And, over years, began opening up to friends. I was (am!) still careful about who I tell. Trust is earned, not assumed. And though I no longer feel shame about my husband's infidelity, there are parts of my life I keep private. And there's a difference between secret and private.
For instance, I don't widely share (except on this blog, in which I remain relatively anonymous) about my daughters' mental health challenges. There are people in my life with whom I'm close who don't know my eldest was hospitalized. I don't hide that. But I respect my eldest's wish to keep it, mostly, private. That's a choice rooted in healthy decision making. Not shame.
Similarly, though plenty know about my husband's infidelity in our city, many more do not. It was long ago. He has done much work. It isn't what defines him or our marriage. And so we, mostly, keep it private.
We haven't told our children, not out of shame but for many other reasons. We keep it private, something some experts such as Caroline Madden, a family therapist, supports and encourages. Others do not. Our choice.
I share my story when I think it can do some good. Either for me or for the person on the other end of it.
And that's where I hope you can all get to. I wish you an army of people in your life who can love you through this pain. Who can listen to you, without judgement. Who can see your pain and run toward it, not away. Those people are, sadly, rare. But their fear of your pain is rooted in their own shame and secrecy. It's a consequence of their own inability to talk about hard things. 
Life is a marathon of hard things. If we never learn how to talk about them, we fail to learn how to really life. Authentically. Deeply. And too often, we don't heal from those hard things. We don't grow from them.
You get to choose what's private and what's not. But secrets? Exorcise those. Be honest about them, at least with yourself. Cultivate relationships with people who don't operate from fear but who are honest about their own struggles. 
Find your family, built on honesty and a willingness to hold each other up. 

31 comments:

  1. I kept quiet for many years. Then after the last D Day when a couple of people around town knew of his infidelity because they saw him out with another woman, and not me his wife, and word was apparently getting around at his work, and they were people that talk, well, There was no secret anymore. Our marriage was over, so I didn't need to protect him, nor did I want to. He never cared to protect me and my heart. I did find opening up to people, they in-turn opened up also. And geez. The amount of people going through betrayal or unhappy marriages is really sad. So many unhappy people.
    Hugs
    Gabby xo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's been my experience too, Gabby. I tell one person and sure enough, they've either gone through it or their best friend is or their mother did or... Infidelity is like a quiet epidemic, ravaging families while we pretend it isn't happening.

      Delete
  2. I didn't tell anyone because it would have affected so many people My husband is a Pastor. He had an emotional affair. To some, not telling is in itself betrayal, and to others, it is walking a fine line between secrecy and betraying those who feel they ought to know. There were many factors that played into his affair and believe it or not, I readily understood how it could happen. That in no way excused his behavior or lessened my pain, but I've seen how my husband has dealt with others who have confessed their sins to him and felt he deserved that same treatment. There are a few in our church that would have eaten my husband alive and a lifetime of faithful, compassionate ministry would have been called into question which would have affected even more people. And I was in so much pain that I just couldn't inflict that same pain on my children as well and have to deal with my pain and theirs. And then there was the pain that would have been inflicted on church members, many who had been with our church for their whole lifetimes who love and trust my husband, and up until this happened, for good reason. They would have been devastated. I just couldn't have handled all of that at once so I made the choice to forgive my husband and believe that God would heal and redeem our marriage.

    It was very hard for me and after about 8 months of silence and secrecy, I found someone I could trust to talk to. And yes, I stayed. And yes, we are healing. And yes, it's still hard sometimes because my mind goes crazy and thinks, is he staying because he needs me to be the loving Pastor's wife on Sunday mornings or because he really wants me?

    I still grieve what I thought we had. My Hallmark movie has ended, but not like a Hallmark movie should end. I've stepped into the real world now and am learning how to love with God's love first, even when it still hurts, even when I'm not sure what my feelings are yet, and even when I realize that I may be setting myself up for disappointment. But then I think, can I really waste my life when I'm loving someone with the love that God showed me? Was it not His kindness that led me to repentance and restored my relationship with Him? Can't that same kind of love do the same in my relationship with my husband? And so I continue...to trust God first and foremost, to listen for His voice and leading in my life and to love my husband with all the love that God can put in my heart for him at this time and in this circumstance. I don't know what the ending will be yet to my new movie, but I do know that I am a better, stronger, person, wife, and mother because of it and if he turns out to just be a cheater that cheats, I will be better equipped to brave a whole new world on my own and to be there for those that it will hurt. This may be foolish to some. Heck, some days it looks foolish to me but I have to follow the path that I believe God would have me follow knowing that He will never leave me or forsake me and that He is with me every step of the way, with or without my husband whom I have loved for so many, many years.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank-you for your lovely response. That's all each of can really do, isn't it? Take the next right step. And then the one after that. And so on.
      And yes, it can be hard to figure out who to tell. There will definitely be those who think they are "owed" the truth about us. But we get to decide that. Based on our own reasoning.

      Delete
  3. I remember telling both of our children that we were having issues but we were working our way through it...as adults, I’m sure they had suspicions but they didn’t ask for details...as a family we’re each aware of how we ourselves all four of us have our own demons we are dealing with...I’m having a hard time cleaning out our family home that now belongs to my sister and me...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cleaning out a family home undoubtedly brings up all sorts of emotions. I hope you can take it day by day. It's an act of love to do it with intention, I think.

      Delete
    2. Theresa - I too am cleaning out my dad's house. It's been over 5 years. And I've avoided doing it because it brings such immense pain. I was over there last night - I needed to get out of my own house and it's time I did something about dad's house (either to rent ... or for me and the kids to move into) ... and I stood sobbing in the kitchen.

      I started finding hidden jewels. Things that seriously I have NO idea why they were just out in plain sight ... but it was a little comforting thinking that maybe, just maybe I wasn't truly alone in this pain right now. My parents were there with me.

      It's all I've got ... the hope ...

      Delete
    3. Theresa, I had to do some of this, this past weekend too. We are nearing the end of the cleanout and have even started to divide the things we want vs what to sell, thrift etc. My sister is a wonder at this. I went in with the idea that I don't actually need any of that stuff. Its just stuff and I will be doing a downsizing in a couple of years myself anyway. I've lived without it this long. So it made decision making a lot easier. So I kept a cool old tea set with dragons that I had loved since a kid. I got the brass wind up alarm clock that woke my dad for work every day for the entirety of his life. Both small. Both neato. And both I could have left if my sis really wanted them. At the same time, all that decision making is exhausting. Being in that old house and looking back a little at just how dysfunctional it was, and how, once my father's steadying influence was removed, my mom's crazy and mess and hoarding took over. But I think the best part of that process was that my sis reached out fr help because she was feeling so burnt out (we are on opposite sides of the state) and I showed up lickety split. That's the part that maters to me. That house now belongs to my sis and me, and we may rent it out for a few years to get past the medicaid lookback, then likely sell it (also my income will be much lower, so the tax implications of the sale will be reduced.) So much adulting.

      Delete
  4. I’ve told very few people and I do believe that it’s out of shame and fear of judgment. I know that it had nothing to do with me but I can’t bear the thought of anyone I trust with my story telling me my husband will definitely do it again or that I’m naive for staying.
    There have been days where I wished could just tell someone..anyone, to get it out of my system. Even though I know it’s not my fault, carrying the secret often feels like a burden.
    I really believe that having someone to (aside from my therapist and my husband) would have helped the healing. I do wonder if that’s why it seems to be taking so long for me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dandelion!! How are you?
      You might find, with time, that you are able to be more candid with people. It has taken me years but I'm far less reticent to tell people now. I'm still careful in that I only share it with people who I've come to trust or when it's information they can benefit from (ie, they're telling me their husband is cheating) but it can feel good to not hold that secret so close. I hope you can release that shame. It isn't yours.

      Delete
  5. Just finished listening to your podcast with Samuel. Love hearing your voice and your process for the site! In thinking about your post, I recall how much I struggled with not getting the validation from people around me that I needed. Unfortunately there are atleast 30 people in the world who know what happened so I didn't have to tell very many people. I had to let go of anonymity and privacy and hold my head up high. But very, very few really got it and that caused me alot of pain. But one of the things that got me through that disappointment and additional heartbreak was my therapist pointing out that I didn't need other people's permission for how to feel or what to do. I learned to validate myself, trust my experience, and own my story... even if it changed from day to day. I decided that I wasn't going to scurry and hide in the face of such public humiliation. I stopped questioning whether I was right or wrong about how I was feeling. I found that as I got more solid around that, as I said what I had to say and shared what was true with people who were important to me, then people around me started to get it. It took a long time but my mom and sisters finally get it. They now recognize the stuff in their own relationships and I am now the family authority on standing up for yourself in a relationship and my honesty has opened them up to sharing their stories.
    I certainly made mistakes around telling some people but I have found my transparency with people has encouraged them to open up and be honest with me about things. But I don't necessarily think you have to tell people if it doesn't make sense in your situation, but do all you can to eject the shame from your story. That is how I recovered my dignity in the face of humiliation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Awww...thank-you. Samual was a pleasure to speak with.

      Delete
  6. 3 of my closest friends know, but I haven't told one person in my family - I'm scared they'll tell me to leave, I'm scared they'll hate him, I'm scared they'll change my mind, I'm scared I won'd be able to protect him, I'm scared of harsher judgement than I already judge myself for staying.

    For me, the silence comes from fear - and I even feel shame about that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Spouse,
      I'm curious about your fear of their opinions about how you should respond. Is it because you value their opinions over your own? Is it because what you suspect they'll say is what you secretly believe but don't want to? Is it that you'll feel compelled to do what they think you should do? I think that fear can teach you something but you need to look at it clinically.
      In the meantime, I hope you can release the shame. You are doing your absolute best in a situation that nobody should have to deal with. Your husband's behaviour is HIS problem. Your job is to heal you.

      Delete
  7. I finally finished listening to the podcast and I just heard your calm voice that I have been ‘reading’ for a few years...thanks for sharing your story with us out loud! Hugs

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Theresa,
      Glad you listened in. And calm?? Wow...that's a shift. ;)

      Delete
  8. Only one couple knows about my husbands' infidelity. I just don't want to deal with the judgement or unhelpful comments. We are trying to work through this and the situation is complicated--we had been disconnected for a while, he has cancer, and I was away taking care of my dying mom (who none of us knew was even sick) and he had a 6 month affair. (Then kept lying for another 7.) He is working on his issues; I just learned the extent of his childhood trauma, which he thought he had buried. The devastation has been brutal. The way I see the world has shifted so radically. But what I struggle with is that he brought her into the home. I have no safe place. Throughout this process, the only things that have helped besides therapy is this blog, and scientific papers, but I can't find any research or stores where the husband has brought the AP into the home. Does anyone have experience with this, or know of any resources?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous
      My h moved his ow into the house we shared for his work... I had to remodel both the house and then the yard to rid my mind of the fact that this house was in her mind to be their forever love nest...disgusting to remember everything that it took to continue living under this roof... I feel your pain! She spent months in my place during the first renovation of the house! She posted pictures of her time spent on our deck but it took me to help my h get her out of our lives...

      Delete
  9. I am feeling ashamed 2 1/2 years post dday and feeling like my husband and I are not making enough progress.This is my secret. After two years of therapy with the kids and them finally allowing him in to their world again and other family and friends in our lives moving forward I am the one stuck. I keep this a secret because it would cause pain to so many. Am I asking to much of him? I question myself daily. I think on some levels he is trying but may not be capable of what I need. He is in the restaurant hotel industry and allows boundaries to be crossed . Is it too much to ask for him to not be FB friends with servers he supervises? Maybe....but then I see the message " I am going to miss youuuuuu!!" before his vacation from work. Could be innocent but I would never message this to my boss or someone else's husband. He doesn't respond to me with understanding but irritation. We discussed not giving his cell phone number to customers in marriage counseling, ( a customer was the COW) bu he continues to do this. Women send messages like .". Are you busy? I'm thinking of stopping by for a drink" . Why they have to text him? He says they want vip treatment and to have recognition....I am not comfortable with this. Maybe his job success does depend on all of this? I am certain there are some personality disorders with him but he oozes charm. Makes me feel crazy and yet I know so much more about him than even his family. ( Including some recent theft which I also have kept secret hoping he will work through these issues) .I am ashamed to say I don't know his world view and who he really is after 22 years of marriage I also keep this secret to not hurt my kids.Thanks as always for letting me come to this site whenever my heart is so heavy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh dear, Anon. You are dealing with alot. He sounds like a real piece of work.The question that comes to mind when I read your post is: "Where did you learn to live on crumbs?" He is throwing you crumbs. What do you think you deserve?
      I hope you find some relief from this craziness.

      Delete
    2. Anonymous,
      It sounds as though you really struggle with healthy boundaries. Are you expecting too much? Is is too much to ask...? No. It is not. Your feelings are valid. Your needs are legitimate. You get to ask for what you need/want, especially right now when you're working so hard to keep your family intact.
      Try and make a list -- a literal, written list -- of what you want/need from him. And then tell him. Or rather, make it clear that this isn't negotiable. You are giving him the incredible gift of a second chance. The least he can do is support you and make the way as easy as he possibly can. You might want to also search "boundaries" on this site and elsewhere to learn more about setting and managing them.

      Delete
  10. Thank you for seeing me here. Thank you for reminding me these are crumbs. I know none of you know me and I have sought out counseling, but staying strong in trusting myself is hard. I need some factual mantras to repeat to myself to keep me grounded in the reality of all of this.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous, Yes we see you. We know your pain. And I'm glad that YOU can see that you're settling for crumbs. You deserve better than this. You deserve to be treated with kindness and dignity and respect. Begin by giving that to yourself.

      Delete
  11. Selfcare... front and center.. if its feeling hard ... for the moment dont focus on him ... FOCUS ON YOU? What do you need? A walk in the park? A pedicure .. pretty toes help! Daily routine of excercise or maybe a half hour along in car, in starbucks anywhere to just be ... be let the worries wash over you for 15 mins and then say outloud ENOUGH for today .. you cant control him but you can control you ... stay watchful but honey try nit to drive yourself crazy. I am not sure how far out you are and i know early on i was consumed by the affair and deception its still there ... it does wrap around and choke me like before but its there in the rear view mirror. I dont think your crazy i dont think your requesta are unfair i think you deserve piece of mind you deserve to feel safe and im sorry you are going thru this ... you are stronger then you knew and think ... we are all ... wounded warrior princess... i chant im wounded not broken on hard days. I look for sparkle in little things and i remind myself daily ive worked hard for all i have and i deserve to be happy even on days i have to selfcare and focus to find it. You will again ... time is sometomes a 4 letter fuck on hard days and fast ... too fast on the good. Hang in there restaurant wife. You got this.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your words and aupport

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    3. So part 2 if anyone sees this, . The same women who texted she is stopping by for a drink, the next week texted him " I must say....you are very attractive". He responded you are too before he deleted the text . He is "just playing" . Trying to get more customers. Really? Am I crazy or is this outright flirtation and a very dangerous game especially for a man that has not won back the trust of his painfully would describe wife? I confronted him and insisted he text her to please not text like this anymore.. he did angrily. I can't help but feel he will just cover his tracks better and I am back to 2 1/2 years ago of no trust. When he tried to minimize it I reminded him how much was at stake. Sorry I need so much help on this. I am wondering if this is the wnd for us. This text happened on our wedding anniversary....I did not receive a text compliment ...

      Delete
    4. Anonymous - I'm sorry you're in this place. They don't understand how their actions are not just the actions of today but send us back into their actions of yesterday.

      I do wonder, however, what his defensiveness might indicate? I always pay attention to reactions more than I do to my WS's words because they tell far more.

      And yes - they do learn how to hide after caught. But their behaviors eventually come to light.

      Trust your gut!

      Delete
    5. Anon, you are not crazy and his behavior is in appropriate in the extreme. It is not "just playing". It is a dangerous and slippery slope and it is hurtful to you. But he can't see that because it is feeding some deep unmet insecurity and need in him to feel something, desirable? attractive? powerful? whatever it is, his efforts to attract customers or provide them with a great experience are not coming from a place of generosity but from a place of making himself feel good. Its really very selfish and that fact tat he dismisses the pain it is causing you is problematic. Are you two seeing a couples' therapist? Perhaps you should. Is HE seeing an individual therapist? He definitely should because he needs to unpack why this behavior is more important to him that he's risking his marriage. Anon, what are your requirements? What doe she need to do to earn this second chance with you? As MBS says above, you are living on crumbs and you don't need to settle for that anymore.

      Delete
    6. I agree with SS1 and Wounded. If you are not in therapy, I urge you to find someone to help you navigate this and to help you begin to answer the crucial questions around what do I need. I suspect you've never really considered that a valid question. It is.

      Delete
  12. Thank you all. You strengthen me. In therapy, I got to a place of realizing I will probably not be able to trust him again- for more than one reason, but I still hope . I am trying to hold on for one last year until my youngest graduates to avoid senior year chaos for her. I had hoped I would see some miracle this year, but as of right now, you are right I am only surviving on crumbs. He attends a Victories for men group, but refuses individual and marriage therapy. I was hoping the Victories group would help him to a place that he could engage in more therapy. Trying to focus on preparing myself to make decisions and changes next year and stay strong until then. Thanks again for standing with me.

    ReplyDelete

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails