Our stories are not carved in stone. |
~Geneen Roth, This Messy Magnificent Life
My childhood was miserable. And it was magical. When I was five years old, my mother read 2001: A Space Odyssey to me and my eight-year brother, passing along her passion for books and stories. My father spent freezing nights flooding our back yard for an ice rink so we could skate through the Canadian winter.
I would wake to the sound of my parents fighting. Slurred accusations. Loud threats.
As I've grown older, my story seems more complicated. As my parents grew older, they seemed more complicated. I adored my mother, who died after 25 years of sobriety, the same mother who routinely called me selfish in my teens and insisted I cared about nobody but myself. My father, who celebrated his 89th birthday last week, is one of my favorite people in the world. He's kind and generous, a true gentle man. But he's also the dad who, when I was 14, left me to cook and clean and tend to my alcoholic mother, while he sat in his chair with a glass of rye and a cigarette, consumed by self-pity.
Stories from our past, as Geneen Roth says, can become so rigid that they might as well be bars, locking us behind them.
"If we believe them we are defined by them," writes Roth. She isn't suggesting that our stories aren't true, of course. Our husbands cheated on us. That is indisputable. No, what she's suggesting is that the stories we attach to what happens to us can become shackles. And that they are much more open to interpretation.
Take for instance, this familiar story: My husband cheated. He couldn't possibly love me and do such a thing. I mean nothing to him and that isn't going to change.
Maybe you're telling yourself this story. I certainly did. And I believed every word.
I clung to that story as gospel truth.
And it stopped me from doing anything other than stewing in my own misery, even as a tiny part of me doubted its veracity. Yes he cheated on me. But was it true that he couldn't possibly love me or was that part of an old story? Was it true that I meant nothing to him? Was it true that our marriage was never going to change?
The story of my parents' betrayal of me had kept me in bad situations for years before I realized that I had the agency to change my own life. My husband's betrayal of me was such a familiar one, I knew it by heart. And underscoring every word of it was this: There is something wrong with me. I am unloveable. This will never change.
Because I believed that story, I was defined by it. And it paralyzed me.
But our stories do not predict the future. They tell us nothing about "forever". Our stories have something to teach us, absolutely. But the lesson might just be what's written between the lines. The stories we tell ourselves about our stories.
My mother got sober. My father got saner. My husband wrestled with some old demons. I got clearer about what I will and will not tolerate in my life. I treated myself as lovable and began to see that it is true.
The story I'd been telling myself about my miserable childhood wasn't the whole story. There was magic there too.
This is so beautiful. Thank you. My heart is filled with so much love today, on a gray rainy day, simply because I know I can change how I tell myself my own stories. And I know, even when the old voices tell me otherwise, that there is nothing wrong with me and that I am worthy of and deserving of love.
ReplyDeleteI know I stewed in my own misery for along time especially knowing that these women who planned the destruction of my marriage, drugged my husband and played with his paycheck and his mind knowing he was sick, were going about their lives like nothing ever happened. Well karma caught up with them and these women have lost their jobs over the last month. Now I can really let this go knowing that some form of justice was taken care of. Have a wonderful day ladies.
ReplyDeleteHonestly, Elle, I strive to be like you. I will hit the 3 year D-day mark in mid June so I recognize that I have a long way to go to be able to accept, internalize and create an updated narrative of my life but you are a much welcomed beacon of light for this weary traveler. It is his callous use of prostitutes that keeps me in the struggle of acceptance. Maybe we need a new page for spouses of sex addicts? God knows we have crazy stories.
ReplyDeleteOMG Beach Girl--do we ever have crazy stories!! The only thing that has kept me sane, is that he chose hookers. That may sound absolutely crazy to someone who is not in this position. Had my H actually pursued women in the real world (because he is such an introvert) and had he started "real" talk with "real" women, I don't think i could have handled it. That they were whores doesn't make it "better" but for some reason, I think it's easier for me. Finding out about he first girl was puzzling--perplexing, and that was alongside the rage and pain and ALL the rest of the crap we've all gone though on D-Day. Finding out weeks later that it was not a woman of the streets, but an actual streetwalker was easier for me. I think I saw it. selfishly as an upperhand though, as in "you had to pay for it you fucking loser". I could tell myself none of this stuff was real, as i believe most of it was NOT real...they wanted his money not his undying affection. He was just another 'john' and I made not one bit of difference to them. business transaction that he fell for over and over again, hooker, line and sink.
DeleteSteam,
DeleteYour take on prostitutes makes total sense to me. After coming to terms with much of what my H chose, it's the flirting, the hand-holding, the chase... that bothers me more than sex. I get past it most days be reminding myself it was still transactional... 2 people getting paid with adrenaline instead of cash.
That’s a really good point, ann. On many levels it is transactional. My H got his ego stroked and his porn addiction fed. She traded dirty sex for compliments and a few lunches. Ick.
DeleteMy sex addict spouse pursued real women, but I look at them as equal to or even less than prostitutes because he never had to pay them.
DeleteThey meant mo more or no less than a hooker, these women were just "things".
Steam u are rught... its not easy to deal with the fact that your husband strays no matter what the situation.. but i have thought for a long time I would have loved it to be a prostitute, 50 in fact over the brutality of his affair with a single person . He is a psychopath.
DeleteElle you are a Canadian... me too:) Lots of love ladies. My eyes have been really bothering me this week.. I guess I have to be grateful for what I still have. He could have knocked her up. That would have sucked. Loving just looking at my kids faces. Studying them every chance I get.
Blindsided
I'm 3 years from dday, and some days I get weary of our story. I find my mind wandering about whether not trying to hold it all together might have been easier. Then I think of all the good things from these past 3 years and it reminds me to live in the now, not the past or the future.
DeleteHazel - I keep wondering if that feeling ever goes away. Would it have been easier to just throw out the dirty water rather than trying to sit there and pick out the dirt and try to make it clean again.
DeleteI just keep repeating to myself - I'm ok at this moment. At this moment, I'm ok.
But damn if the thought of "I should have left" doesn't keep coming back. I think it's because I feel weak that I didn't. Like I couldn't even stand up for myself enough to say I'm NOT taking this shit anymore and I deserve better. Or I was too afraid to leave because I was afraid he wouldn't follow after me and fight for me.
Kimberly,
DeleteIt wouldn't matter if he fought for you if you don't believe you're worth fighting for. Whether or not anyone else sees your value doesn't matter if YOU don't see it. And I wonder if that's what's keeping you stuck in this limbo.
I know exactly where you are because I've been there. I spent my whole life wondering why people didn't fight for me. I put boyfriends through the wringer to "test" whether they loved me "enough". And it was never enough. No matter that they came back. No matter that they put up with all sorts of shit. It was never enough because I didn't believe I was worth it. It was never enough because I had a hole inside me that nothing outside of me could fill.
You are okay at this moment, Kimberly. But I think you could be more than okay at this moment, whether he becomes a better man or not. But I think it starts with you beginning to recognize your own value, with treating yourself like you matter, with setting really clear boundaries about what is and is not okay in your marriage. I know how tough it is when you've got little kids and it's all you can do to find time to shower. But maybe it's time for this guy to step up and give you more time and space so that you can really begin to heal yourself.
Cause the feeling does go away. I promise. But only when you trust that you are whole, with or without him.
Damnit Elle -- you made me cry.
DeleteTears of recognition?? Seriously, Kimberly, it's time to make room for you in your life. See if you can figure out how, or ask women here for what they did. I suspect, as a recent post discussed, you're settling for crumbs.
DeleteElle - sadly tears of recognition.
DeleteI almost didn't comment back on this ... but then I saw the Featured Post on the right. I need to print that out ... plaster it everywhere ... to remind myself that I should be respected.
My morning commute has always been my reflection time and since I'm back to work I've had that this week. I can tell you a million different times in my life where I have tip toed around people as to not make waves. You learn that quickly as a child with dysfunctional parents. You also learn to keep up a facade of sorts to protect yourself from explosions. Sad that I'm almost 40, have a lucrative career, manage the household finances and my dad's estate ... but I can't break those habits from my childhood.
I also have had time to let anger come back instead of the "poor woe is me" that I've been harboring for the past few months. I'm so sick to death of hearing what he can't do ... what he's not comfortable doing ... FUCK that! You weren't uncomfortable getting out of your shell to post a sex ad on Craiglist ... to meet women ... to flirt with, woo, etc. enough to get her into bed with you ... so it's time he comes out of his shell to meet my needs.
Now to go back to demand that he read Chapter 6 of After the Affair ... he's had 10 months to do so ... no better time than the present right?
That's exactly right. If he's dragging his heels doing what you're asking it's either of two things: a) he can get away with it or b) he doesn't care. I suspect it's (a). But once you start drawing clear boundaries (ie. you need to read Chapter 6 of this book for me by this Friday at 9 p.m. because I need to know you're willing to gain insight into blah blah blah). Not to sound like a drill sergeant (though, well, you might) but to make it clear that you are done tippy-toeing around his "discomfort". He wants discomfort? Try discovering the person you trusted has betrayed you. That's fucking discomfort.
DeleteBeach Girl and Steam, oh my gosh, do we have crazy stories....I truly would not believe this if I weren't living it.
ReplyDeleteMy husband did not pay for sex (well, not from "professionals" - he did give at least one of his affair partners money)so I can't relate to that. Steam, I have a friend whose husband did use prostitutes and feels the same way you do, that it would be worse if it were real women, as in my case. My husband let me go in to the office, interact and make small talk with the women he was screwing around with. I threw him a birthday party years ago and one of them came, with her husband. They are swingers, and her husband knew everything, so the three of them had this little secret that night. My husband says he talked to her prior to the party to make sure she wasn't going to let it slip to me about what was going on. The disrespect and humiliation that he inflicted and allowed them to inflict on me is unfathomable. He has never shown true remorse, a few mumbled "I can't believe what I've done. I'm sorry" but that's pretty much the extent of his remorse. He gets angry and defensive and turns every conversation around, to his pain and suffering, and how hard this has been on him. To this day, nothing is his fault, it's because of his childhood and his sex addiction. I agree that he had a terrible childhood, but I asked for almost twenty years if he was having an affair. He lied to my face, told me I was crazy. Then D-day, and I found out I was right all along.
I opened a personal account right after D-day, told him about it and he agreed, even signed the agreement I drew up, that it would never be considered a joint asset if we divorced - it would be a means of support for me until I could get on my own feet financially. Well, we're divorcing and he's going ballistic over that account. Says I took advantage of him when he was vulnerable, and he was not in a frame of mind to make an agreement like that, because of his addiction. This person lied to my face, told these other women he wasn't getting enough at home and that our sex life was "vanilla", exposed me to herpes and never told me, even through two pregnancies. I have ptsd, lost about 30 percent of my hair (it's growing back, thank God)have been seeing an IC and trauma therapist, and will probably never trust anyone again. And I took advantage of him.... This is a nightmare.
HeartinFlight, i SO feel for you. It really is the deceit even more than the sex that is too much. at least for me it IS. the fact that others were in on the secret behind your back is horrifying to me. Being blindsided like that is just humiliating, although, i know in my heart and my brain, and you should too, that I am not the one who should be humiliated. . In my case before anything had happened I met one woman. It was brief but while I was in the bathroom this "party planner" came clean to my husband, with what those parties really were, and that she could take care of everything--me included. and the next thing you know (8 months later) I find texts on his phone and then their saved conversations, that I too was not just vanilla, but had DECIDED that I never wanted to have sex again. Good lord, the lies they make up. She is the only person who knew I existed, the only one I ever met and the fact that they had this bullshit secret is the thing that drove me nuts...of course I was already nuts from D-day 1 2.5 years previous, also with a hooker. Oh the book I could write! He detailed all his escapades online so I was "lucky" enough to read about all of them, his thoughts on them, and even their massive HANGNAILS. he spared no details. How long ago did this happen to you? I'm glad your hair is coming back and you are getting help. In situations like this there is no playbook we are privy too until the plays have been made. the only way I made it through was counseling. I wish ONLY the best for you.
DeleteWas his cow paid? Yes but not like a hooker! She was given money to go buy clothes when her x won custody of their children and the house because she divorced as an adulterous wife and my h was the one that picked her up from the gutter and moved her into our house! That said he paid for her to play volleyball and bought her ear rings because she lost a favorite. These things he told me about because she was blowing up my phone with bits and pieces of exaggerated truth. Biggest truth he cheated bigger truth he lied by omission over and over and those truths are what just about did us in. I’m not as angry as I was then but I can trigger and boom I feel rage but I’m more capable of using this rage to accomplish garden chores and exercise. Each of our stories are different but the raw emotions are so similar! Thinking of you all in the pain I know so well!
ReplyDelete