Monday, April 15, 2019

On trust and vulnerability and why it's still so damn hard

Trust is choosing to make something that is important to you, vulnerable to someone else's actions.
~Brené Brown, Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations

My heart beats quicker even writing those words. Because I know that, for all that I profess to have moved on from my husband's betrayal, for all that I claim to be through that pain, trust is still really hard for me. Still. 
Perhaps, always.
Cause I don't really remember a time when I fully trusted. Well, except one. I fully trusted my husband. For perhaps the first time in my life, I had absolute faith that this person would not betray me. That he, above all others, was worthy of my trust.
It had taken me a long road to get to that point. When you grow up in a home where trust is routinely betrayed, where promises are consistently broken, where what you see with your own eyes is called into question, then trust is impossible. You learn that not only others are untrustworthy but that you are. When gaslighting is a daily occurrence, when you're told that you're the crazy one for pointing out what's there – right there! see it? – you stop believing anything and anyone. You hold your breath and when the people you surround yourself inevitably reveal themselves as untrustworthy, then you blame yourself. Because there is clearly something about you that makes you undeserving of commitment and loyalty. The occasional times when someone entered my orbit who was trustworthy? Well, I betrayed their trust because what sort of loser wants to be with me? There was clearly something wrong with them. Better to dispense with them now.
The sisterhood? That was the stuff of fiction. Girls were the worst, as far as I was concerned. I expected men to disappoint me. But occasionally I allowed myself to believe that my girlfriends were true blue. Indoctrinated by sitcoms and teen novels, I imagined a world where a friend would never betray me, where my secrets would be safe, where I could be vulnerable. 
The reality was gossip and backstabbing and, in my early 20s, a devastating betrayal by a friend. 
But all along, I clung to some deep belief that maybe, with help, I could trust myself. Despite consistent gaslighting by a family who insisted that I made things up, I held on to the truth like a life raft. I wasn't crazy, they were. I wasn't making things up, they were. After all, I would say to myself, who's a more reliable narrator: the sober kid watching or the parent who's six drinks in? 
But D-Day robbed me of even that tenuous hold I had on self-trust. I had been so wrong. And if I was wrong about him then, surely, I was wrong about everything. About everyone. 
Healing from my husband's betrayal became an exercise in learning to trust myself. Him? Forget that. Wasn't going to happen. But I knew that my only path toward healing had to be through learning how to trust myself.
I began with a thorough excavation of a whole lot of painful experiences – times when others challenged what I knew to be true. Times when I betrayed myself by choosing their version of events over my own. 
And then I started trying to discern that same small still voice – the one who had been right all those times and that I had ignored. It's there. I promise it's there. Dormant perhaps because, after all, nobody was listening. But nudge it awake. Tell it that you're listening now. 
It's still hard for me. Too often, I prioritize others' versions over my own. It still requires intention to nudge that voice awake because I ignore it too often.
But I'm getting better at it. There's work to be done, clearly. Otherwise my heart wouldn't ache slightly when I typed BrenĂ© Brown's words. I suspect it will be the work of my lifetime. Those old messages make deep tracks in our hearts. 
But I can look around now and notice all the people that surround me now. Family and friends that inspire trust. People with whom I can – sometimes! if I try really really hard! – make myself vulnerable. And, almost, trust that I will be safe. 

25 comments:

  1. Trust
    The original trust is gone but I do trust that he has learned from his choices because he spent last weekend nursing me through the worst of the pneumonia and ear infection that I have ever had! I’m still not completely well but he’s stepped up and he did all the cooking and cleaning and keeping up with my medicine so that I can take my time and heal at my own pace just as he did with his horrible betrayal and we all know that that’s going to take a life time for true healing!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I had blind trust with my husband, despite my early experiences. I was so certain.
      Now I trust him differently. I know what he's capable but I trust him to keep himself in check. I trust him to choose differently. And I trust that, if he does betray me again, it will not have been a thoughtless choice but an intentional one. He will have chosen to exit our marriage.

      Delete
    2. Elle, wow, you just articulated what I was trying to tell my husband two days ago after a couple of things. I'm going to have to repeat this to him the next time this comes up. "I trust him to choose differently and if he does betray me again he will have chosen to exit our marriage." Wow, that is so clear. Thanks again for being you.

      Delete
  2. Trust, I too trusted nobody until I met and married my husband. Never again will I ever trust him unconditionally again. I only trust myself and sometimes I am even wrong there but it is far less painful to learn from my own lessons than to look this man in the eye and know what he did to me and to himself. I know I will never know the full truth of all that he did because all that he did went on prior to meeting me and continued until well after D-day with the trickle truths. I do trust that he has learned a hard lesson and I believe that he accepts that I will never trust him again unconditionally but we do have conversations now that are hard, especially when I have reminders or triggers because I need to know what's real and what's not real. Just yesterday we had another conversation because one of his best friends sent him a photo of the cover of some ancient Playb*y magazine and commented on it. I knew because we were talking to the friend on speaker when he said he sent that to my husband. Last night I asked my husband, "What happened in your brain when you saw that photo?" He replied, "I thought, well I did not need to see that photo and I am not interested in that at all so I deleted it." He again told me that he is 100% honest with me now and that he is honest with everyone as he never wants to be that guy again. His behavior indicates that he is 100% devoted to me and wants me to be happy but the unspoken understanding is that his past choices, lies and deceptions were so severe that there is no going back with me. If he wants to have unconditional trust, we need to divorce and he can start all over again with someone with whom he can be honest with from the beginning. He doesn't want to do that so he lives with the consequences of his 40 years of deception and lies and hopes that someday I will look at him as trustworthy again. Life is not bad but it is not what I anticipated it would look like more than forty years ago when I fell in love with a chameleon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, life is not what I anticipated either but I wonder if that's true for pretty much all of us, whether or not we've experienced infidelity.

      Delete
    2. That seems to be where we are. He was such an expert liar that he has no way to prove he is telling the truth being sincere or does really care. His actions are admirable but they always were. The actions he allowed the world to see. He keeps saying' Why would I still be here'. Well, why were you here lying daily?' Good question but he doesn't have an acceptable answer. I am trying to stay so his vile choices do not crush our children like he did me. I am not sure if I can do it. Praying for strength

      Delete
  3. I trust in myself, no one else. Who in the hell said I have to trust anyone in the first place? It is not a virtue anyway. Trust is about the last thing on my mind. Poof, it just disappeared when he he broke his vows. I'm vulnerable in other ways that do not have a big cost factor. Trust cost too much to give it away, again. I'm some type charity for the untrustworthy. Do I get lulled into some type of trust sleep? Yes, I do and that is damn scary. There is nothing that is unconditional anymore. He went into a nuclear waste vagina site why would I want to trust that? Yes, my H, had done it all to keep me. Yes, he did deserve a second chance, we all do. No second chance on trust for me. When you say you prioritize other's versions over your own, I do that too. I told my H, he keeps promises to himself, not others. I keep promises to others and not myself.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I had the opportunity to help another betrayed wife, early in the discovery. I hurt for her. I listened and listened. I could see clearly the OW was a master manipulator. I could see right through her shenanigans. The OW is older than the cheater, knows the ropes so to speak. My friend wasn't ready to hear much. I wanted to go home and beat up my cheater but I didn't. I can see how everyone's past life experiences play a big role in healing. The betrayed have to go through a healing process. You can't rush it. You can't give advice that she isn't ready to hear. Every boundary was broken for his second chance. She is beautiful, lovely, kind, caring and just a good person. She can't see that yet but she will. I have learned so much from this site so I could help someone else. It is like walking through a nuclear waste world. I could see her strength and his weaknesses. I could see her hopium that her marriage would survive. But her hopium was slowly eroded bit by bit. He did the cruelest thing I have ever seen, he sent her a text with a picture of the OW and him. How cruel. She is getting a divorce and she threw the hopium in the trash.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, our experience does situate us uniquely to see betrayal so clearly, particularly when it's happening to someone else. Your friend is lucky to have you, LLP. But I wonder too if watching her experience also helped you work through some of your own pain. It can feel disorienting -- I have a married couple/friends who are dealing with it right now and calling on me for guidance -- but it also forces me to reckon with some of my own residual stuff.

      Delete
  5. Trusting myself is the hardest thing, as someone who was taught from a young age that what she saw or thought she knew just wasn't true. And never feeling safe because no one ever came along side me to show me how, as my therapist often says, when we talk about growing up with an alcoholic mother. She often asks, why do you expect yourself to know things that no one ever taught you? And it is a good question. Especially around trust. Why should I expect myself to just easily, magically trust anyone, including myself, when I was not taught how to do so or taught how to do so safely, when in fact my training was just the opposite. And then I kept choosing people who confirmed that bias. And now, when I am with a person, who has been proving himself trustworthy over and over (and generous, and kind, and unselfish) I don't know what to do or how to totally let go. And maybe I don't need to do that yet. Maybe I can let go or lean in by degrees and trust myself that that is the right process for me. trusting myself has been coming up so much lately, in my work and life, if must be the theme and project of now. I think I'm on to something. But it means being really uncomfortable and not checking out or bolting (which I have been doing, old habits resurrecting perhaps to be exorcised). But it means maybe believing that I can trust myself around food, around alcohol and around people, just like I have learned to trust myself around money. Its a start. I think before we can trust other people, we need to learn to trust ourselves.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think the leaning in is a really important thing to notice. It isn't an all-in/all-out proposition. People earn our trust, in degrees. Even good, kind, generous people earn their way into our hearts in increments. That's normal. But for those of us raised with dysfunction, I think we struggle with that. We assume that people are either totally trustworthy or not at all.

      Delete
  6. I worked so hard on really trying to trust HIM again. But soon I found out it wasn't that I needed to learn to trust HIM instead learn to trust ME again. Once I figured that puzzle out trusting him became less important.

    Trusting myself after DDay was very difficult because how could a bright person such as myself be so stupid not to have seen it?? How could I, someone who prided herself on having good intuition, not have seen what was going on right under my own nose? In a way by not trusting myself I was also taking on the blame of HIS choices. How arrogant of me :)

    Trusting myself has become my number one priority. Trusting others not so much. To say I trust him or anyone else for that matter would be a lie. I still trust no one. I keep most at arms length and I am ok with it.

    Me on the other hand? I really listen and trust that small voice. I don't call her dramatic anymore. I validate her and pay attention.

    Thanks Elle for this post.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is the absolute key -- when we trust ourselves then whether others are trustworthy becomes more clear and less relevant.
      I too listen to that small voice. It has always been there and, honestly, has always known what's best.

      Delete
  7. I too had to learn to trust myself too. I also watch closely since I think a huge piece of this was my husband did not trust or believe in himself. When he was cheating he obviously lowered his boundaries but I see that is a common habit for him. I continue to remind him he needs to think carefully about his boundaries. It is puzzling to me how he can let them fall so easily. He is a million times better but what he did regarding betrayal is seen in all aspects of his life.

    ReplyDelete
  8. My husband also struggles with boundaries in ALL aspects of his life. When we talk about it, it almost seems like a foreign concept to him. Difficult because he is not a communicator. Better but it is tough for him to talk about feelings. ❤

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mine does too. He never learned in childhood so it's like a language he can't quite grasp. But I've found that all the work I've done to understand boundaries, and framing things for him in that language (ie. noting that one of our kids' friends doesn't have clear boundaries around what's appropriate in our house, etc.) has helped him. Has your husband sought any sort of therapy? That might help him.

      Delete
  9. Should it be easier if he emotionally/mentally cheated while we were dating.....before engagement and marriage. There are so many people out there who have had this happen and physical cheating while married. I feel like my situation is a drop in a pond. What makes it hard is it was with his childs mother, his ex fiance. People tell me he chose me, he chose to marry me. He said it stopped when he realized he wanted to be with me for good. I dont know what to feel. This girl isnt going away and she's a master manipulator and will not respect boundaries that we've set surrounding contact and communication.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Idontknow, We talk a lot on this site about the pain-olympics. This isn't a contest. Betrayal is devastating. No matter whether you were married or not. You trusted this man and he betrayed that trust. And it hurts like hell. No "drop in the pond" at all. You're allowed to acknowledge how much it hurts.
      I'm glad he realized his mistake but it remains to be seen whether he understands how he allowed himself to do it in the first place. And then to keep it a secret for so long. To marry you with that secret looming.
      What's more, she's in his and your life for a long time, which puts you in a really difficult situation, having to face the so-called Other Woman regularly. That's incredibly unfair to you.
      I would strongly encourage you to get couples counselling to help you navigate this and so he can truly come to understand the damage he's caused. I'm wondering if he's minimizing it ("we weren't married", "I stopped", etc.).

      Delete
  10. I have a similar situation. My husband kept it a secret that he had a child with a woman he was seeing shortly before we met. He is using the fact that it happened before we met and got married as an excuse. He feels like he doesnt owe me any explanation where in actual fact this woman and her child are in our lives. He has been visisting them sectretly and communicating via email so i wouldn't see the messages. He doesnt understand the depth of my pain and disappointment. I have so many questions of which he refuses to answer and on top of that he is denying that the child is his but has not gone for a DNA test in 5 years. I can't believe i married a liar. All of this feels so unreal as if i am goting to wake up and live the fairytale life i imagined i would have

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Gemini N,
      Your husband has a very strange idea around what he doesn't owe you explanations of. He had a child with another woman. That's pretty huge. What's more, he's keeping them in HIS life secretly. As the old saying goes, if it wasn't a big deal (and a threat to your marriage), then he wouldn't be keeping it a secret, would he?
      I know you're reeling from this. Most of us are in the early days. But give some thought to what you want to do next. Figure out what we call our "next right step". Don't worry about a year or two or three. Just what's next. Do you want to leave? Do you want to try and rebuild a marriage with this man? If so, what does that need to look like in order for you to be happy in it? Does he need therapy (I vote a strong YES to this one)? What about couples counselling? What about visiting a lawyer to ensure your finances are protected? One step at a time. Just one.
      I know that feeling that this must be a nightmare from which you're going to wake up. It's a shock. My most recent post is about trauma, because that's what a lot of us are feeling. If you don't already have a therapist to support you through this, please find one. You need someone with YOUR best interests at heart to help you navigate this.
      I'm glad you found us too. Your'e among an incredible group of women, none of who ever thought we'd need to be here. But here we are. Lifting each other up. Reminding each other that we're stronger than we know. That we'll get through this.

      Delete
    2. Gemini--I have no advice other than affirm what Elle has said. I do have compassion for your situation. It is awful when you think you are living one kind of life and then the truth hits and you find out differently. I am so sorry he chose to keep a secret life from you and it's not right on any level. I hope you are firm and honest with him about your thoughts that this is not ok. And yes, one day at a time.

      Delete
  11. Trust. Such a short and small word but it means so much. It's been 3 months since D-day and this is the 2nd infidelity. I joke that I'm handling this 2nd time around much better because of practice. I've been trying to not come from hate but rather from love and understanding...though the rage does come out time to time. I don't trust my husband but the truth is, I don't trust myself. I feel like it's becoming harder and harder to deal with the infidelity and myself. I want to establish boundaries and gain control back...but I don't even know what that is anymore. My husband continues to have the affair and we are supposed to move to another State in 2 months. I just can't see myself leaving my home in this mess. He has disrespected our marriage and continues to do so. Part of me thinks the best thing is to leave and get a divorce but for some reason I just can't seem to get myself there.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous,
      He's continuing with the affair? That's excruciating. And you should not have to put up with that at all. What is stopping you from leaving?

      Delete
    2. It has been excruciating. I woke up today with guts. I wrote my husband an email letting him know I've been hurting and gave him an ultimatum. I told him if he did not set up therapy appt for us with the infidelity specialist I found (I had set up an appt originally but he backed out) by our anniversary (in 3 weeks), then I will file a response to his divorce. He filed a little over a month ago but has not served me yet. I feel that's a start. It'll at least give me some insight, even if it still ends in divorce.

      Today, I've been reviewing all of the information I received from the 3 lawyers I spoke with. I'm reviewing my finances to make sure I'll be ok. My hope is to keep the home we are in but knowing my husband, he may fight me to the end.

      I'm scared on this new adventure. I've spent 13 years with my husband (married 6 years). I've supported him all throughout to pursue his career. He's finishing up the final phase of his residency and I feel I've been kicked to the curb after all of the support and sacrifices I've made. I feel like I'm an outcast in my own marriage. I think I was afraid of the unknown and really never thought I'd be in this position. All my life I believed in working out the marriage and fighting and thinking that it's never greener on the other side.

      Delete
    3. Anonymous, I'm so glad you've taken steps to protect yourself financially and REALLY glad that you're setting clear boundaries around what you will and will not tolerate. You are worth fighting for. You deserve so much better than this. I hope you'll keep us posted. Whatever happens, please know that you are going to be just fine. With time, yes. But absolutely fine.

      Delete

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails